HL.b.1 Economics studies how humans produce, distribute and consume goods and services, both individually and collectively.
HL.b.2 Environmental economics is economics applied to the environment and environmental issues.
HL.b.3 Market failure occurs when the allocation of goods and services by the free market imposes negative impacts on the environment.
HL.b.4 When the market fails to prevent negative impacts, the polluter-pays principle may be applied.
HL.b.5 “Greenwashing” or “green sheen” is where companies use marketing to give themselves a more environmentally friendly image.
HL.b.6 The tragedy of the commons highlights the problem where property rights are not clearly delineated and no market price is attached to a common good, resulting in overexploitation.
HL.b.7 Environmental accounting is the attempt to attach economic value to natural resources and their depletion.
HL.b.8 In some cases, economic value can be established by use, but this is not the case for non-use values.
HL.b.9 Ecological economics is different from environmental economics in that it views the economy as a subsystem of Earth’s larger biosphere and the social system as being a sub component of ecology.
HL.b.10 While the economic valuation of ecosystem services is addressed by environmental economics, there is an even greater emphasis in ecological economics.
HL.b.11 Economic growth is the change in the total market value of goods and services in a country over a period and is usually measured as the annual percentage change in GDP.
HL.b.12 Economic growth is influenced by supply and demand, and may be perceived as a measure of prosperity.
HL.b.13 Economic growth has impacts on environmental welfare.
HL.b.14 Eco-economic decoupling is the notion of separating economic growth from environmental degradation.
HL.b.15 Ecological economics supports the need for degrowth, zero growth or slow growth, and advocates planned reduction in consumption and production, particularly in high-income countries.
HL.b.16 Ecological economists support a slow/no/zero growth model.
HL.b.17 The circular economy and doughnut economics models can be seen as applications of ecological economics for sustainability.
Economics looks at how humans
produce,
distribute
consume
goods and services, both individually and collectively.
Focus is the supply and demand of resources and the outcomes of market interaction.
Focus excludes examination of..
where the resources come from,
what happens to any pollution that might be produced as a byproduct of production,
what we do with the goods when they are finished with (waste).
In sum, the process involves: Take - Make - Use - Lose
Market supplies a product when there is a demand
Research is often done to establish the moral values of the market
Some businesses encourage demands i.e in fashion, food and automotive.
Ecological economics [First Venn diagram]
is a subset of economics
is based on seeing the human economy as a subsystem of the global ecological system.
the economy and society are seen to be within the environmental sphere.
aims to insert the environment into economics and prioritise its management, in an area where it has been traditionally neglected
doesn’t try and integrate society and the environment into an economic framework where these aspects can be uncomfortable. Instead, ecological economics views material and income flows within an economy as part of the larger transfer of materials and energy within the biosphere.
evaluates sustainable development as being a condition where the scale of the economy doesn’t exceed the ultimate carrying capacity of the planet
deviate so far from the norm and not make use of the current economic lexicon
isolation from influential decision makers
does not regard economic, social and environmental capital as substitutable. Therefore a fall in environmental capital cannot be offset by rises in capital in other areas.
Environmental Economics [Second Venn diagram]
is a subset of economics
Environmental economics is a subset of economics that is based on a modified neoclassical economic model
borrows a worldview and terminology from existing theories of economic growth and development.
fully integrates concepts such as welfare and capital from existing theories but applies them to environmental ends
evaluates development as an accumulation of social capital and economic capital minus the reduction in environmental capital
development can be deemed to be sustainable where total capital stocks do not decline
assumes high level of substitutability and complementarity between these different forms of capital
Evaluate the pros and cons
List the 10 thinks you should
Stephen Smith, author of Environmental Economics: A Very Short Introduction, gives us an insight into what environmental economists do, what environmental economics is about, and how it measures and influences our impact on the environment. He also explores the steps we need to take to protect it at an international level. Do you agree with all of Stephen’s points? Let us know in the comments section below.
Left to its own devices, a free market economy will not deliver the level of environmental quality that people want. Firms can pollute and consumers can make choices without concern for the environmental consequences. What we need is some level of environmental regulation and intervention to ensure that those decisions take into account those of the rest of society.
Environmental economics is about this necessary intervention in the workings of the economy. It’s about the questions of: how much environmental quality do we want and what’s the best way of getting it?
Environmental economics is not a dogma. It’s a framework for thinking about the fundamental choices and trade-offs in environmental policy. It can be used quite flexibly to think about a range of different issues in environmental policy and problems. On the local scale for example, local industrial pollution, right through to the major problems of global climate change.
Eliminating pollution entirely is unlikely to be feasible or indeed desirable. What environmental economics helps us to do is to think about the costs and benefits, the advantages and disadvantages of more or less environmental protection.
Environmental economists are skeptical about conventional legal approaches to environmental regulation. So-called ‘command-and-control’ approaches to environmental regulation (based on detailed legal instructions) tend to be inflexible and excessively costly.
Market mechanisms which use prices and taxes to discourage pollution are more flexible and can achieve reductions in pollution, at a lower-cost.
Emissions trading systems like, ‘The EU Emissions Trading System for Carbon Dioxide’, reduce pollution by putting a firm cap on emissions and by allowing firms to trade. Firms that have high costs in reducing emissions can buy permits from firms that are able to achieve emissions reductions more cheaply. In this way, the system reduces the overall economic cost of achieving a given environmental outcome.
A lot of research in environmental economics is about trying to assess people’s concerns about the environment in the broadest possible way. Environmental economics is not simply about the costs and benefits for company accounts, or things that cost money in the economy. It involves a much broader view of social value and environmental benefit.
Tackling climate change will need co-ordinated international action. It’s a global problem affected by the global concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. Individual countries acting alone can make only a very small impact on the overall problem, and would incur significant costs from any action they take. A meaningful international deal on climate change is the only way in which we will likely to make significant progress.
Tackling climate change will require major changes in the way that our economy produces and uses energy and in the decisions of firms and individuals about production and consumption. The economists argument is that these major changes spread across all of society will be achieved at much lower economic cost, and much more effectively with much less disruption to the way in which we produce and consume, than if we tried to achieve the same outcomes through detailed legal prescription about how people behave.
From: https://blog.oup.com/2016/05/ten-facts-environmental-economics/
A market failure is achieved when the economical pursuit causes the degradation of the environment i.e unsustainable practice
This may be caused by greenwashing and/or tragedy of the common
Greenwashing
is a misleading or deceptive PR approach in persuading the public into believing that the company's policy, products and goals are environmental friendly
Activity
Make a poster / infrographic to summarise
To what extent greenwashing impacted the environment using named examples?
Fashion
Oil and gas
Automotive
Tragedy of the commons
is a concept where individuals with access to a public resource (also called a common) act in their own interest and ultimately deplete the source i.e unsustainably exploiting the common resources
Degrowth, zero growth or slow growth are concurrent with ecological economics
Decoupling: Economic growth does not mean environmental degradation
From the CNBC video,
rich countries would provide universal incomes, reduced working weeks and job guarantees to reduce inequalities which the least wealth countries would be encouraged to keep growing their economies, at least to the levels of middle-income countries in a sustainable way.
This would focus on reducing the demands of energy and materials (consumption and production) in rich countries.
Scotland, Iceland and New Zealand have said they will prioritise wellbeing rather than solely focusing on economic growth
Bhutan has their model of Gross National Happiness which focuses on Happiness rather than GDP.
Bhutan has also been looking at the role of Doughnut Economics as a tool to support this.
What are circular economy and doughnut economics?
models that support the development of sustainability through the lens of ecological economics.
ensures that all inputs are recycled within the system
entering a biological stream of composting
components can be re-used in new products.
addresses issues of inequality and injustice by resetting the economic frame
everyone is in the safe space
everyone is practicing standards within planetary boundaries.